- Post-summit signal. US envoy Jared Kushner said in Berlin on Thursday that Russia is “comfortable” with the idea of Article 5-like security guarantees for Ukraine — the first public framing of a potential settlement architecture after the Shenzhen trilateral.
- Not confirmed by Moscow. The Kremlin has not publicly endorsed Kushner’s characterisation, and Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov has separately called NATO-style membership for Ukraine “unacceptable.”
- Ukraine’s fear. Kyiv fears that any deal shaped by Washington and Moscow could be imposed rather than negotiated, with European allies sidelined from the final terms.
Twenty-four hours after President Trump held his first three-way summit with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping in Shenzhen, senior US envoy Jared Kushner appeared in Berlin on Thursday to brief Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and more than 40 European leaders on what the meeting had produced. The centrepiece of his remarks was a claim that Russia had shown it could accept security guarantees for Ukraine modelled on NATO’s Article 5 mutual-defence clause.
“We’re comfortable working toward a framework built on Article 5 principles,” Kushner said, according to reporting by PBS and the Associated Press. Trump joined the Berlin session by phone shortly after his bilateral with Putin concluded.
What Kushner said — and left unsaid
Kushner offered no detail on the mechanism by which Article 5-like guarantees would be enforced, nor which countries would be expected to provide them. He said Trump remained open to a guarantee if it served American interests, but did not define what that meant for US troop commitments or treaty obligations.
The Berlin meeting was designed to show European allies — many of whom fear they are being cut out of a Washington-Moscow negotiation — that their views on postwar security arrangements matter. Zelenskyy participated alongside leaders from across the EU and NATO membership, and the stated goal was to build a “unified position on the key elements of a lasting peace.”
The limits of the claim
Moscow did not confirm Kushner’s framing. The Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov declined to comment on any European negotiating agenda, and Ryabkov’s separate statement calling NATO-adjacent arrangements for Ukraine “unacceptable” remained on the record. The absence of a Russian endorsement is not incidental: a security guarantee is only as credible as the party it is meant to deter acknowledges it.
Ukraine struck the Kerch Bridge several times in the four days surrounding the Berlin meeting, and Putin vowed a response. That military tempo sits uneasily alongside the diplomatic language coming out of Shenzhen and Berlin, suggesting that neither side is yet prepared to freeze the conflict.
As covered here when the Shenzhen summit produced a joint statement with no concrete breakthrough, the gap between agreeing to language about peace and agreeing to a mechanism for achieving it remains large. Kushner’s Berlin statement edges that conversation forward, but does not cross it.
What Europe wants
European governments have repeatedly said they want a seat at any negotiating table that produces security arrangements on their continent. Several leaders arrived in Berlin with specific demands: that any guarantor roster include major European powers, that Ukraine’s territorial position not be formalised in a way that accepts Russian-held land as sovereign territory, and that any arrangement include a sanctions-relief schedule tied to compliance.
None of those items has been publicly agreed by Washington or Moscow. The next round of talks has no confirmed date.